Posted on: December 4, 2024, 06:19h.
Last updated on: December 4, 2024, 06:19h.
California’s Graton Rancheria tribe (FIGR) has filed a lawsuit that seeks to torpedo the Koi Nation’s efforts to build a casino in Sonoma County in the heart of the state’s wine country.
FIGR is also based in Sonoma County where it operates the Graton Hotel & Casino in Rohnert Park, just 15 miles away from the proposed Koi Nation site. It has long opposed the Nation’s application to the federal government to have the land taken into trust for the casino project and has accused the tribe of “reservation shopping.”
“Taking land into trust” describes the process by which the federal government converts land into tribal territory, partially removing it from the jurisdiction of the state, which is a requirement for tribal gaming.
One Step from Approval
Two weeks ago, the U.S. Interior Department’s Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA) completed its final environmental impact study (FEIS) for the Koi Nation project. That means the casino is one step away from approval, with a decision expected soon after December 23.
But the Graton Rancheria’s complaint argues the Koi Nation has no ancestral ties to the land. It claims the BIA failed to do its due diligence when it looked into the tribe’s history.
One of the conditions of the land in trust process is that a tribe should be able to demonstrate a historical connection to the land. But according to the lawsuit, the plot in Sonoma County is “outside of the Koi Nation’s aboriginal territory and historic rancheria, which are located over 50 miles to the north.”
The Tribe and other Southern Pomo tribes in Sonoma County remain inextricably connected to and protective of their culture and history in the area of Windsor and the Project Site in Sonoma County,” the lawsuit states.
“The Southern Pomo language and culture are distinct from that of other Pomo tribes, such as the Southeastern Pomo Koi Nation, and these linguistic, cultural, and territorial boundaries have persisted over millennia,” it adds.
Bad Faith
In a written statement to SFGATE this week, Koi Nation spokesperson Sam Singer called the lawsuit “meritless,” adding it was filed in “bad faith” as “an effort at gamesmanship to circumvent the BIA’s legal and regulatory process to advance Graton’s own economic interest.”
The lawsuit names Interior Secretary Deb Haaland, as well as several officials within the BIA and other federal agencies.
It asks the court to enjoin the defendants from making any final decision on the land until they complete a “legally adequate” consultation process with FIGR and other culturally affiliated tribes.
